Still a Way To Go for Carp


Why the “carp virus” plan is taking longer than expected — and what it could mean for the Murray

If you’ve spent any time around the Murray in Sunraysia, you’ve probably seen them: carp cruising the shallows, stirring up the bottom like a toddler in a sandpit, and turning a nice clear patch of water into a murky soup.




So it’s no surprise a lot of locals prick their ears up whenever the “carp virus” gets mentioned. This is because it sounds like the magic fix we’ve all been waiting for.

But here’s the update in plain English: we’re still years away from any decision, and the government’s timeline now points to 2028 before ministers decide whether it gets released into Australian waterways.

Let’s break it down without the science headache.


Why carp are such a problem

Carp aren’t just an “annoying fish.” In some waterways they make up a massive chunk of the fish population, and their habits can cause real damage:

  • They feed by vacuuming along the bottom, which stirs up sediment

  • That can cloud the water, making it harder for plants to grow

  • Less plant life means less shelter and food for native fish

  • And it can flow on to the whole river system — birds, bugs, everything

In other words: when carp numbers explode, the river pays for it.


What’s the “carp virus” everyone talks about?

The proposed tool is a virus known internationally as Cyprinid herpesvirus 3 (you’ll also hear it called
koi herpesvirus).

The big idea is simple:
release the virus → it spreads through carp → carp numbers drop → river health improves.

Sounds straightforward… but the reason it’s taking so long is because releasing a virus into open rivers is a one-way door. Once it’s out there, it’s out there.

So the question isn’t just “Will it kill carp?”
It’s also:

  • Will it affect other fish or wildlife?

  • How will it spread in real river conditions?

  • What happens if it doesn’t work as well as hoped?

  • What happens if it works too well and we get masses of dead carp?

  • Who cleans that up?

  • What are the environmental flow-on effects?

That’s why they’re being cautious.


Why has it taken this long?

Research started years ago under the National Carp Control Plan, and it’s been one of the biggest biological control investigations Australia has ever looked at.

And despite early hopes that a release could happen sooner, the government has now locked in more research through to 2028.

So while the headlines can make it sound like “they’re dragging their feet,” what’s really happening is they’re still trying to answer the hard questions, especially around safety, real-world transmission, and environmental impacts.


What happens between now and 2028?

From what’s been flagged publicly, the focus is on:

  • proving it’s carp-specific

  • understanding how it behaves in Australian waterways

  • modelling different river systems (because the Murray isn’t the same as every other river)

  • preparing for the “what ifs” — including how to manage any large-scale carp deaths

  • and tightening up the final cost/benefit picture

Then in 2028, the final “yes or no” call will be made by state, territory and federal agriculture ministers.


What could it mean for Sunraysia if it does happen?

This is the part that matters locally.

If a carp control program genuinely knocks numbers down, the potential upside is huge:

  • clearer water in some stretches

  • improved habitat and food sources for native fish

  • healthier riverbanks and aquatic plant life over time

  • a better overall Murray River experience for locals and visitors.. boating, kayaking, fishing, riverside camping… the lot

But there’s also the very real practical side:
if carp start dying in big numbers, the community will want to know who’s responsible for clean-up, how it’s funded, and how impacts are managed.

So even in a best-case scenario, this wouldn’t be a “set and forget” solution — it would need planning, resources, and probably other carp-control methods working alongside it.


Where are we up to?

Right now, the carp virus idea is still exactly that: an option being researched, not a done deal.

  • More research is underway

  • The program is set to run through to 2028

  • Then ministers decide whether it’s released..  or shelved

So yes… still a way to go for carp.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Popular Stories